SERIES REVIEW >> LUNG TING TSANG PA


Date Aired: 1989
No. of Episodes: 20

Cast & Characters


Eddie Cheung Siu Fai --- The 4th Prince
Gallen Lo Ka Leung --- Sum Chi
Margie Tsang Wah Sin --- Princess Yee Lan
Eugina Lau Mei Kuen --- Fong Kwan Wah
Nathan Chan Ting Wai --- Sum Hung
Lam Kei Yan --- Cheung Yan Yan
Bobby Au Yeung Chun Wah --- The 1st Prince
Carrie Choi Ka Lei

 

Review

"Lung Ting Tsang Pa" is one of many Eddie Cheung - Gallen Lo collaborations. I can name a few off the top of my head: Plain Love, The Hunter's Prey, and Cold Blood Warm Heart. It is also one of many Eddie Cheung - Margie Tsang collaborations, although they weren't paired up together in this series.

"Lung Ting" is unique in a way that Eddie is the lead, and he is (ultimately) the bad guy. I don't know if there is an official English title for this series, but I once saw it translated as "The Battle in the Royal Court" and found it to be quite accurate. This is a tale of one prince's bloody struggle to get to the throne, eliminating those precious to him if they stood in his way. But he wasn't all that bad to start with... in fact, quite the opposite. So the story begins.

Eddie is the fourth prince of the Ming Dynasty, obviously far removed from the next line in throne since he has three older brothers. The first prince, Bobby, is sickly and can be indecisive. The second and third princes are evil and conspire to get rid of the first prince so they can be in power. Eddie takes on the responsibility of taking care of his oldest brother. Eddie is indeed a prince charming - well-educated, good in martial arts, handsome, has good manners, you name it, he has it all.

Gallen is a member of the White Lotus Sect. The sect is on the brink of extinction because they are constantly hunted by the government. This goes all the way to the beginning of the dynasty when the founder, Chu Yuen Cheung, was afraid of the sect's rebellion and ordered them to be annihilated. Ever since then, the sect members have been running about, hiding and secretly building their power in hopes of restoring their previous glory.

When Eddie and Gallen meet, despite their differences, they soon become good friends. Gallen has hopes in Eddie that he will help the people of their nation and his sect. Eddie and Gallen fall in love with Eugina and Margie, respectively. Eugina is the foster daughter of a well-respected former general, and Margie is a spoiled princess from the neighboring nation. Gallen's older brother, Nathan, is a hot-tempered but good-natured guy. Nathan accidentally reveals that Gallen is not his "real" brother, even though they have camaraderie like no other. Gallen seeks for his biological father, who ends up being Eugina's foster dad.

Fast-forwarding a little bit, Eddie's two evil older brothers throw a failed coup and in turn, end up begging for their lives. Eddie promises to spare them, but ends up killing them instead. This upsets his father, the emperor, greatly, and cements his decision to make Bobby as the next emperor. Eddie is so upset by this that he confronts his father. "Why can't you see that I will make a better emperor, that I am more talented?" ponders Eddie. He ends up killing his father as well. This is sort where Eddie starts going bad, but people don't know his true colors yet.

Eddie asks Eugina to marry him and she agrees. Margie and Gallen frequently quarrel, but are supportive of each other. Nathan finds companionship in Lam Kei Yan, who is the daughter of Eddie's henchman (not a good guy).

Somewhere along the series, Bobby is captured by Margie's sister and father (who are not as nice as Margie). He almost goes deaf and is humiliated, while his younger brother, Eddie is filling in for him back in his country. Eddie is enjoying being the "temporary" emperor - until Gallen safely rescues Bobby.

Eddie is really bad by this time, trying to kill Bobby so he can be the emperor. His wife, Eugina, gives birth to his son. She is disgusted by the way he has changed, so she takes off with her baby and Eddie is furious. Gallen finds out that Eddie murdered his dad (also Eugina's foster father) and vows to get revenge. He sides with Bobby, who now wants to fight against his beloved brother. Eddie seems to be winning in this fight - Gallen even loses Nathan, who was captured by his girlfriend (Lam Kei Yan)'s dad and was turned into a zombie. Nathan started attacking Gallen, until he snapped and realized what was happening to him. He demanded Lam Kei Yan to kill him so he wouldn't hurt any more people, so she does so - and takes her own life while giving his funeral.

In the end, Eddie goes full on crazy and even causes Eugina's death. The final duel results in Eddie and Gallen falling off the cliff and dying... or so, Bobby thought. Bobby mourns for Gallen's death (Eddie is really dead). But we see Gallen alive and in disguise, following Margie so they can leave and start their lives in peace.

For some reason, this series did not air in Hong Kong, only overseas. I liked seeing the cool assortment of costumes of the late 80's and a short, 20-episode series focusing on the Ming royalty vs. the White Lotus Sect. It was also nice to see supporting actors like Miu Siu Wai (as Eugina's maid) and Bobby (who was starting to gain a bit of weight here). Carrie Choi starred as Bobby's love interest, though she died tragically.

I watched this series when I was much younger, and I was dismayed by Eddie's fate towards the end. I thought he would've made the better leader and his surroundings had caused him to turn bad. But thinking back on it, I change my mind. It's better for a nation to have an emperor who has compassion and generally cares about the well-being of his people, like Bobby did, than Eddie who killed his own family to get to the throne. I think he showed signs of being a warmonger and winning at all cost, which is never good news for the people who live in his country.

However, I really liked seeing Eddie in this costume drama and couldn't help rooting for his happiness. Also, why wasn't he paired up with Margie like he usually was? That would've been a nice addition, though her ending would've been pretty tragic also.

 


established on 7-15-2004
written by Clair

[ SERIES ] [ HOME ]